PB
The People's BibleScripture Unlocked • By the People, For the People
3-Layer Interactive Reader • 66-Book Bible

Job Chapter 24

Showing all 25 verses for Job Chapter 24.

💡 How to Use The People's Bible Chapter Reader

The People's Bible is written by people, for the people. Each verse below shows:

📜 1. Original KJV VerseHover over highlighted Jacobean 1611 words to see modern shift definitions.
🏛️ 2. Original LexiconView original Hebrew/Greek roots and 1st-century historical exegesis context.
✍️ 3. Interpret & ApproveApprove submitted verse (💖), contest wording (🚩), or click + Add your interpretation to submit your own interpretation.
Job 24:1
📜 Original KJV VerseJob 24:1

"Why, seeing times are not hidden from the Almighty, do they that know him not see his days? "

🏛️ Original Language Illumination:
Original Term:Root Analysis (job 24:1) (Hebrew)
Range of Meanings:This is Job's central complaint in this chapter — not that there's no justice at all, but that it's invisible, delayed, unpredictable. He wants to know why goodness doesn't come with a clear timetable people can count on.
Why It Matters Here:Job opens a new complaint: if God truly knows the timing of everything, why doesn't he make his justice visible and timely to those who trust him? This launches a long, vivid description of injustice going unpunished.
✨ Suggested InterpretationsSynthesized from 1 public contribution(s)
"Since times of judgement aren't hidden from the Almighty, why don't those who know him ever see his days of reckoning?"
🌱 Modern Life Connection & Pastoral Antidote:

Wanting to see justice on a clear timeline is a deeply human ache, and I won't tell you it's wrong to feel it. What I ask is that you keep doing right in the meantime, rather than letting delayed justice talk you out of your own integrity.

Job 24:2
📜 Original KJV VerseJob 24:2

"Some remove the landmarks; they violently take away flocks, and feed thereof. "

🏛️ Original Language Illumination:
Original Term:Root Analysis (job 24:2) (Hebrew)
Range of Meanings:Moving a boundary stone was a serious violation in ancient law — a quiet, deniable way to steal a neighbour's land bit by bit. Job is naming concrete, everyday injustice, not abstract theology.
Why It Matters Here:Job begins a detailed, unflinching description of real injustice in the world — starting with land theft and violent robbery of livestock, crimes that go unpunished right in front of everyone.
✨ Suggested InterpretationsSynthesized from 1 public contribution(s)
"Some people move boundary markers to steal land; they violently seize flocks and then graze them as their own."
🌱 Modern Life Connection & Pastoral Antidote:

Small, quiet dishonesty — nudging a boundary, taking a little more than your share — is still theft, even if no one catches you. Integrity means being honest in the small unseen moves, not just the big obvious ones.

Job 24:3
📜 Original KJV VerseJob 24:3

"They drive away the ass of the fatherless, they take the widow’s ox for a pledge. "

🏛️ Original Language Illumination:
Original Term:Root Analysis (job 24:3) (Hebrew)
Range of Meanings:These aren't abstract sins; they're targeted exploitation of people with no power to resist, robbing them of their basic means of livelihood — exactly the kind of behaviour Eliphaz falsely accused Job of in chapter 22.
Why It Matters Here:Job continues cataloguing specific abuses against the most vulnerable — orphans and widows losing the very animals they depend on for survival, taken by the powerful with impunity.
✨ Suggested InterpretationsSynthesized from 1 public contribution(s)
"They drive off the orphan's donkey, and take the widow's ox as collateral for a debt."
🌱 Modern Life Connection & Pastoral Antidote:

Exploiting people who have no way to fight back is one of the clearest wrongs there is. If you have any power in a situation — financial, social, physical — use it to protect people who don't, not to take even the little they have left.

Job 24:4
📜 Original KJV VerseJob 24:4

"They turn the needy out of the way: the poor of the earth hide themselves together. "

🏛️ Original Language Illumination:
Original Term:Root Analysis (job 24:4) (Hebrew)
Range of Meanings:This paints a picture of structural, not just individual, injustice — a whole underclass pushed to the margins by those with power, unable even to move freely without being displaced.
Why It Matters Here:Job describes systemic marginalisation — the poor denied access, justice, or even public space, forced to band together simply to survive.
✨ Suggested InterpretationsSynthesized from 1 public contribution(s)
"They push the needy off the road, and the poor of the land are forced into hiding together."
🌱 Modern Life Connection & Pastoral Antidote:

Ask yourself who's being quietly pushed to the margins around you — at work, in your community, in the systems you take for granted — and whether your own comfort depends on not noticing them. Real love pays attention to who's been shoved aside.

Job 24:5
📜 Original KJV VerseJob 24:5

"Behold, as wild asses in the desert, go they forth to their work; rising betimes for a prey: the wilderness yieldeth food for them and for their children. "

🏛️ Original Language Illumination:
Original Term:Root Analysis (job 24:5) (Hebrew)
Range of Meanings:The comparison to wild donkeys isn't meant to demean the poor but to capture their stripped-down, precarious existence — no security, no margin, just relentless daily foraging to keep their children fed.
Why It Matters Here:Job shifts to describe the desperate daily existence forced on the poor by the exploitation just described — reduced to a hand-to-mouth, animal-like struggle for survival.
✨ Suggested InterpretationsSynthesized from 1 public contribution(s)
"Like wild donkeys in the desert, the poor go out to their work, rising early to hunt for food; the wasteland provides what they can scrape together for themselves and their children."
🌱 Modern Life Connection & Pastoral Antidote:

Never look down on someone whose life has been reduced to daily survival — that reduction is usually the result of what's been taken from them, not a flaw in their character. See the dignity underneath the desperation.

Job 24:6
📜 Original KJV VerseJob 24:6

"They reap every one his corn in the field: and they gather the vintage of the wicked. "

🏛️ Original Language Illumination:
Original Term:Root Analysis (job 24:6) (Hebrew)
Range of Meanings:This depicts exploitative labour: people doing the work while someone else, described as 'wicked,' owns the harvest — an ancient picture of what we'd now call unjust or exploitative employment.
Why It Matters Here:Job describes the poor labouring on land owned by exploitative masters — working hard but with no ownership or fair share of what they produce.
✨ Suggested InterpretationsSynthesized from 1 public contribution(s)
"They harvest a field that isn't theirs, and glean the vineyard that belongs to a wicked man."
🌱 Modern Life Connection & Pastoral Antidote:

Fair pay for real work isn't a small thing — it's a matter of basic justice. If people are labouring to produce wealth they never get to share in, that imbalance matters to me, and it should matter to you too.

Job 24:7
📜 Original KJV VerseJob 24:7

"They cause the naked to lodge without clothing, that they have no covering in the cold. "

🏛️ Original Language Illumination:
Original Term:Root Analysis (job 24:7) (Hebrew)
Range of Meanings:This is a stark, physical image of neglect — not abstract injustice but literal cold, bare skin, no blanket. Job wants his friends (and the reader) to feel the actual human cost of the systems he's describing.
Why It Matters Here:Job continues detailing the physical suffering inflicted on the poor by exploitative treatment — stripped of even basic clothing and warmth.
✨ Suggested InterpretationsSynthesized from 1 public contribution(s)
"They leave the naked to sleep with no clothing, nothing to cover them in the cold."
🌱 Modern Life Connection & Pastoral Antidote:

Someone's basic physical comfort — warmth, clothing, shelter — is not a luxury to be earned; it's a baseline every human deserves. When you have the means to cover someone's need, that's not charity, it's simply what love does.

Job 24:8
📜 Original KJV VerseJob 24:8

"They are wet with the showers of the mountains, and embrace the rock for want of a shelter. "

🏛️ Original Language Illumination:
Original Term:Root Analysis (job 24:8) (Hebrew)
Range of Meanings:The detail here (rain, rock, no shelter) makes the suffering visceral and specific rather than abstract — Job wants this injustice to be felt, not just acknowledged intellectually.
Why It Matters Here:Job continues the vivid, physical description of the suffering poor — exposed to the elements with nowhere to hide.
✨ Suggested InterpretationsSynthesized from 1 public contribution(s)
"They're soaked by mountain rains, and huddle against a rock for lack of any shelter."
🌱 Modern Life Connection & Pastoral Antidote:

It's easy to feel general sympathy for 'the poor' as an idea and much harder to picture an actual person soaked and shivering against a rock. Let yourself picture it — specific empathy moves people to act in ways vague sympathy never does.

Job 24:9
📜 Original KJV VerseJob 24:9

"They pluck the fatherless from the breast, and take a pledge of the poor. "

🏛️ Original Language Illumination:
Original Term:Root Analysis (job 24:9) (Hebrew)
Range of Meanings:This is among the most disturbing images in the chapter — a baby torn from its mother, probably to be sold or enslaved for a family debt. Job is not exaggerating for effect; this kind of debt-bondage was a real practice in the ancient world.
Why It Matters Here:Job returns to describing the cruelty of the powerful towards the most defenceless — even nursing infants aren't spared from being seized, likely into debt-slavery.
✨ Suggested InterpretationsSynthesized from 1 public contribution(s)
"They snatch the fatherless child from the breast, and take the poor person's own clothing as collateral for debt."
🌱 Modern Life Connection & Pastoral Antidote:

There's no injustice more urgent than one that harms a child who can't defend themselves at all. Protecting children — especially from systems that would exploit their helplessness — is among the clearest, least negotiable duties love has.

Job 24:10
📜 Original KJV VerseJob 24:10

"They cause him to go naked without clothing, and they take away the sheaf from the hungry; "

🏛️ Original Language Illumination:
Original Term:Root Analysis (job 24:10) (Hebrew)
Range of Meanings:This is a cruel irony: those who grow the food go hungry, because the powerful take even the grain they've harvested, leaving them with nothing despite their labour.
Why It Matters Here:Job continues the litany of exploitation — even the harvest that should feed the hungry is taken away from them by force.
✨ Suggested InterpretationsSynthesized from 1 public contribution(s)
"They force him to go about naked, without clothing, and carry off the sheaves of grain from those who are starving."
🌱 Modern Life Connection & Pastoral Antidote:

It's a particular kind of cruelty to take from someone the very thing they worked to produce for their own survival. Watch for this pattern anywhere — profiting from someone's labour while leaving them with nothing to show for it.

Job 24:11
📜 Original KJV VerseJob 24:11

"Which make oil within their walls, and tread their winepresses, and thirst. "

💡 Highlighted words feature Jacobean 1611 tooltips to clarify shifted 17th-century English terms.

🏛️ Original Language Illumination:
Original Term:Root Analysis (job 24:11) (Hebrew)
Range of Meanings:The irony is deliberate and bitter: labouring in the middle of overflowing resources while personally going without. This is exploitation dressed up as productivity — the workers create the wealth but never taste it.
Why It Matters Here:Job paints a picture of workers surrounded by abundance — oil and wine, symbols of plenty — while remaining thirsty and deprived themselves.
✨ Suggested InterpretationsSynthesized from 1 public contribution(s)
"They press olive oil inside their masters' walls, and tread the winepresses, yet go thirsty themselves."
🌱 Modern Life Connection & Pastoral Antidote:

Being surrounded by abundance you can't share in is one of the loneliest forms of poverty. If your work is generating plenty for others, you deserve a real share of it too — that's not greed, that's fairness.

Job 24:12
📜 Original KJV VerseJob 24:12

"Men groan from out of the city, and the soul of the wounded crieth out: yet God layeth not folly to them. "

🏛️ Original Language Illumination:
Original Term:Root Analysis (job 24:12) (Hebrew)
Range of Meanings:This is Job at his most raw — not denying God's existence or power, but honestly naming that God's justice, from where Job stands, looks absent or delayed. The book doesn't punish Job for saying this; it's presented as legitimate, painful honesty.
Why It Matters Here:Job's complaint reaches its sharpest point: the suffering and dying cry out, but no divine response, no visible justice, comes. This is the emotional core of his frustration with God's apparent silence.
✨ Suggested InterpretationsSynthesized from 1 public contribution(s)
"People groan from within the city, and the wounded cry out for help — yet God doesn't seem to charge anyone with wrongdoing."
🌱 Modern Life Connection & Pastoral Antidote:

If you've ever heard suffering cry out and wondered why nothing seemed to answer, you're not alone, and that question doesn't make you unfaithful. Bring that exact complaint to me directly rather than swallowing it or pretending you don't feel it.

Job 24:13
📜 Original KJV VerseJob 24:13

"They are of those that rebel against the light; they know not the ways thereof, nor abide in the paths thereof. "

🏛️ Original Language Illumination:
Original Term:Root Analysis (job 24:13) (Hebrew)
Range of Meanings:Job uses light and darkness as moral metaphors: those doing wrong actively avoid exposure, showing they know their actions are wrong even as they do them. This connects directly to a theme that reappears strongly in the New Testament.
Why It Matters Here:Job shifts to describing criminals — murderers, adulterers, thieves — who deliberately operate under cover of darkness to avoid being seen doing wrong.
✨ Suggested InterpretationsSynthesized from 1 public contribution(s)
"These are people who rebel against the light — they don't know its ways, and they don't stay on its paths."
🌱 Modern Life Connection & Pastoral Antidote:

If you find yourself hiding an action from the people who love you, that's usually a sign your own conscience already knows the answer. Living in the light — willing to be seen — is one of the simplest tests of whether something is right.

Job 24:14
📜 Original KJV VerseJob 24:14

"The murderer rising with the light killeth the poor and needy, and in the night is as a thief. "

🏛️ Original Language Illumination:
Original Term:Root Analysis (job 24:14) (Hebrew)
Range of Meanings:Job names the poor specifically as the murderer's targets — reinforcing the chapter's whole theme that the powerless bear the worst of society's hidden violence, with the least protection.
Why It Matters Here:Job describes specific criminals timing their violence to avoid detection — striking the vulnerable at dawn, then reverting to thievery under cover of night.
✨ Suggested InterpretationsSynthesized from 1 public contribution(s)
"The murderer rises at first light to kill the poor and needy, and at night he acts like a thief."
🌱 Modern Life Connection & Pastoral Antidote:

Violence against the vulnerable, committed where it won't be seen, is one of the deepest betrayals of trust there is. Stand up for the person who's an easy, unprotected target — that's exactly where courage and love are needed most.

Job 24:15
📜 Original KJV VerseJob 24:15

"The eye also of the adulterer waiteth for the twilight, saying, No eye shall see me: and disguiseth his face. "

🏛️ Original Language Illumination:
Original Term:Root Analysis (job 24:15) (Hebrew)
Range of Meanings:The detail of disguising the face emphasises the deliberate, calculated nature of the deception — this isn't a moment of weakness but a planned act of concealment.
Why It Matters Here:Job continues describing hidden wrongdoing — this time sexual betrayal, timed and disguised to avoid discovery.
✨ Suggested InterpretationsSynthesized from 1 public contribution(s)
"The adulterer's eye watches for twilight, thinking, 'no one will see me,' and he disguises his face."
🌱 Modern Life Connection & Pastoral Antidote:

Betraying someone's trust in secret doesn't make the betrayal smaller — it just adds deception on top of the original wrong. If you're hiding something from the people who trust you, that's worth honestly examining before it's discovered for you.

Job 24:16
📜 Original KJV VerseJob 24:16

"In the dark they dig through houses, which they had marked for themselves in the daytime: they know not the light. "

🏛️ Original Language Illumination:
Original Term:Root Analysis (job 24:16) (Hebrew)
Range of Meanings:This continues the light/darkness contrast — these criminals don't just happen to work at night, they actively avoid the light because it exposes what they're doing.
Why It Matters Here:Job describes burglars planning their crimes in daytime but executing them under cover of darkness, avoiding light entirely.
✨ Suggested InterpretationsSynthesized from 1 public contribution(s)
"In the dark, they break into houses they'd marked out in daylight — they want nothing to do with the light."
🌱 Modern Life Connection & Pastoral Antidote:

Plans made in secret to take advantage of someone rarely survive being said out loud to a person who loves you. If a plan can't bear daylight, that's usually all the answer you need about whether to go through with it.

Job 24:17
📜 Original KJV VerseJob 24:17

"For the morning is to them even as the shadow of death: if one know them, they are in the terrors of the shadow of death. "

🏛️ Original Language Illumination:
Original Term:Root Analysis (job 24:17) (Hebrew)
Range of Meanings:This is a striking psychological observation: prolonged wrongdoing doesn't just hide from light, it eventually reverses a person's whole relationship to it, making exposure the thing to fear most and secrecy the place of comfort.
Why It Matters Here:Job closes this section by noting how completely inverted these people's moral world has become — what should comfort (daylight) terrifies them, and what should terrify (darkness) is their comfort zone.
✨ Suggested InterpretationsSynthesized from 1 public contribution(s)
"For them, morning feels like deep darkness — they're right at home with the terrors of the dark."
🌱 Modern Life Connection & Pastoral Antidote:

Watch what you've become comfortable hiding in — over time, secrecy can start to feel safer than honesty, and that's a warning sign, not a neutral habit. I want you living somewhere daylight doesn't scare you.

Job 24:18
📜 Original KJV VerseJob 24:18

"He is swift as the waters; their portion is cursed in the earth: he beholdeth not the way of the vineyards. "

🏛️ Original Language Illumination:
Original Term:Root Analysis (job 24:18) (Hebrew)
Range of Meanings:This section (through verse 24) has long puzzled readers, since it seems to shift from Job's complaint that the wicked prosper unpunished to describing their inevitable ruin — some scholars think Job may be voicing this ironically or quoting an idea he's testing, but read straightforwardly it shows Job holding both truths together: the wicked often escape immediate consequence, yet do not escape forever.
Why It Matters Here:Job turns to describe the eventual downfall of the wicked — swift, forgotten, and cursed, despite their earlier apparent success.
✨ Suggested InterpretationsSynthesized from 1 public contribution(s)
"He's swept away like foam on the surface of the water; their share of the land is cursed; no one goes near their vineyards."
🌱 Modern Life Connection & Pastoral Antidote:

Even when wrongdoing seems to succeed for a while, that success is never as solid as it looks — nothing built on harming others lasts the way it appears to. Don't let someone else's apparent 'winning' talk you out of living honestly.

Job 24:19
📜 Original KJV VerseJob 24:19

"Drought and heat consume the snow waters: so doth the grave those which have sinned. "

🏛️ Original Language Illumination:
Original Term:Root Analysis (job 24:19) (Hebrew)
Range of Meanings:The imagery emphasises inevitability rather than speed — snowmelt disappears gradually under sustained heat, just as, Job says, the wicked are eventually and surely consumed by death, even if not instantly.
Why It Matters Here:Job uses a natural image — desert heat evaporating meltwater — to describe how death eventually and inevitably consumes the wicked, however long it takes.
✨ Suggested InterpretationsSynthesized from 1 public contribution(s)
"Drought and heat swallow up the melted snow water; the same way, the grave swallows up those who have sinned."
🌱 Modern Life Connection & Pastoral Antidote:

Justice doesn't always arrive with a dramatic strike — sometimes it's slow and quiet, like heat drying up water over time. Patience with a process you can't see moving is still a form of trust.

Job 24:20
📜 Original KJV VerseJob 24:20

"The womb shall forget him; the worm shall feed sweetly on him; he shall be no more remembered; and wickedness shall be broken as a tree. "

🏛️ Original Language Illumination:
Original Term:Root Analysis (job 24:20) (Hebrew)
Range of Meanings:This is a strikingly bleak, unsentimental image of death and forgottenness — no legacy, no memory, just physical decay and a broken, useless end, like a tree snapped rather than gracefully felled.
Why It Matters Here:Job describes the ultimate erasure awaiting the wicked — total oblivion, forgotten even by the mother who bore them, reduced to nothing but decay.
✨ Suggested InterpretationsSynthesized from 1 public contribution(s)
"The womb that bore him forgets him; the worm feasts on him and finds him sweet; he's remembered no more; wickedness is snapped like a tree."
🌱 Modern Life Connection & Pastoral Antidote:

A life built only on taking from others tends to leave nothing lasting behind it — not even memory. If you want to be remembered for something real, build a life around what actually helps people; that's what outlives you.

Job 24:21
📜 Original KJV VerseJob 24:21

"He evil entreateth the barren that beareth not: and doeth not good to the widow. "

🏛️ Original Language Illumination:
Original Term:Root Analysis (job 24:21) (Hebrew)
Range of Meanings:This underlines the chapter's consistent focus: real injustice targets those with the least ability to defend themselves, and Job refuses to let that cruelty go unnamed even while describing eventual downfall.
Why It Matters Here:Job returns to naming the wicked person's specific cruelties — targeting women who are already vulnerable through childlessness or widowhood, groups with little social power in the ancient world.
✨ Suggested InterpretationsSynthesized from 1 public contribution(s)
"He mistreats the childless woman who cannot bear children, and shows no kindness to the widow."
🌱 Modern Life Connection & Pastoral Antidote:

Kindness towards people who are vulnerable and have nothing to offer you in return is one of the clearest tests of real character. Look specifically for who's easy to overlook or mistreat around you, and choose to be kind there.

Job 24:22
📜 Original KJV VerseJob 24:22

"He draweth also the mighty with his power: he riseth up, and no man is sure of life. "

🏛️ Original Language Illumination:
Original Term:Root Analysis (job 24:22) (Hebrew)
Range of Meanings:This reinforces that raw power and apparent invincibility aren't the same as real security; God's authority over even the mightiest oppressor undercuts any illusion of untouchable strength.
Why It Matters Here:Job notes that ultimately, even powerful oppressors are subject to God's power — no human strength guarantees permanent safety, however invincible someone might currently seem.
✨ Suggested InterpretationsSynthesized from 1 public contribution(s)
"Yet God drags away the mighty by his own power; when he rises up, no one's life is secure."
🌱 Modern Life Connection & Pastoral Antidote:

However secure or powerful someone seems, that appearance is never the whole story. Don't build your own sense of worth on power or invincibility — build it on something that doesn't depend on staying on top.

Job 24:23
📜 Original KJV VerseJob 24:23

"Though it be given him to be in safety, whereon he resteth; yet his eyes are upon their ways. "

🏛️ Original Language Illumination:
Original Term:Root Analysis (job 24:23) (Hebrew)
Range of Meanings:This is an important nuance: apparent prosperity of the wicked isn't proof that God doesn't see or care — it may simply mean judgement hasn't come yet. Delay isn't the same as absence.
Why It Matters Here:Job acknowledges that the wicked may currently enjoy a false sense of security, but insists this doesn't mean they've escaped notice — God is still watching, even during their apparent success.
✨ Suggested InterpretationsSynthesized from 1 public contribution(s)
"Though he's granted safety to lean on for now, God's eyes remain fixed on his ways."
🌱 Modern Life Connection & Pastoral Antidote:

Someone getting away with something right now doesn't mean it's been forgotten or overlooked. Live as though you're seen at all times — not out of fear, but because that's simply the truth, and it should shape how you act when no one else is watching.

Job 24:24
📜 Original KJV VerseJob 24:24

"They are exalted for a little while, but are gone and brought low; they are taken out of the way as all other, and cut off as the tops of the ears of corn. "

🏛️ Original Language Illumination:
Original Term:Root Analysis (job 24:24) (Hebrew)
Range of Meanings:The image of grain being cut down is deliberately unremarkable — no dramatic, singled-out punishment, just the same common ending that comes to everyone eventually, wicked or not. It's a sobering, almost anticlimactic picture of mortality.
Why It Matters Here:Job concludes this section by describing the brevity of the wicked's success — however high they rise, their end comes just as ordinarily and inevitably as anyone else's.
✨ Suggested InterpretationsSynthesized from 1 public contribution(s)
"They're raised up for a little while, then they're gone — brought low, gathered up like everyone else, cut off like the tops of grain stalks."
🌱 Modern Life Connection & Pastoral Antidote:

Every life, however it rises, eventually comes down to the same ordinary ending. Let that reality keep you humble rather than either arrogant in success or despairing in struggle — none of it is permanent, so build what actually matters while you can.

Job 24:25
📜 Original KJV VerseJob 24:25

"And if it be not so now, who will make me a liar, and make my speech nothing worth? "

🏛️ Original Language Illumination:
Original Term:Root Analysis (job 24:25) (Hebrew)
Range of Meanings:This is Job standing firmly behind his own testimony about how the world actually works — not the tidy theology of his friends, but the messier, harder truth of injustice that sometimes goes unpunished and sometimes doesn't. He's not backing down.
Why It Matters Here:Job closes chapter 24 with a direct, confident challenge — daring anyone (his friends included) to disprove the honest, unflinching picture of the world he's just described.
✨ Suggested InterpretationsSynthesized from 1 public contribution(s)
"And if this isn't true, who can prove me a liar and show that my words are worthless?"
🌱 Modern Life Connection & Pastoral Antidote:

Speak the truth as you honestly see it, even when it's uncomfortable, and be willing to stand behind it. I don't need you to have a perfectly resolved answer to every hard question — I need you to be honest about what you actually see.